13 Best Carbon Steel Pan of 2022 to Consider
Many professional chefs prefer the best carbon steel pans to cast iron pans for cooking as they are smoother and less brittle. Not only that, but carbon steel pans also heat up faster than cast iron pans, which make them appropriate for broiling, sautéing, frying, and searing. As such, the demand for these pans has […]
Many professional chefs prefer the best carbon steel pans to cast iron pans for cooking as they are smoother and less brittle.
Not only that, but carbon steel pans also heat up faster than cast iron pans, which make them appropriate for broiling, sautéing, frying, and searing. As such, the demand for these pans has risen significantly over the past few years in the US.
However, buying a quality carbon steel pan that is durable and more effective than a non-stick is easier said than done. Since there are many options on the market, choosing the right model that meets your cooking requirements can be confusing and time-consuming.
That is why we decided to make it simpler for you by handpicking the top 13 carbon steel pan options currently available on the market. Furthermore, we have provided a buyer’s guide towards the end of the article to help accelerate your decision-making.
So, without further delay, let’s get straight to the good stuff!
Top Carbon Steel Pans
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | |
|---|---|---|---|
Our Top PickOur Top Pick | Misen 10" Carbon Steel Pan |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | De Buyer Mineral B Frying Pan 5610.32 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Lodge CRS12 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Craft Wok 731W88 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Mauviel 3651.28 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | BK CC002354-001 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Merten & Storck CC003336-001 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Ballarini 75000-891 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Winco CSFP-8 |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
 | Mecete Wok Pan 5th Generation |
| VIEW LATEST PRICE → |
1. Misen 10″ Carbon Steel Pan
Misen is one of the leading manufacturers of high-quality yet affordable cookware in the world. And the Carbon Steel Pan from the brand is certainly no different. Highly efficient and compatible with electric, induction, and gas burners, this product is an option that you simply cannot afford to miss out on.
Why Did We Like It?
We were impressed with its weight and how good it felt in our hands. At 3 pounds, it is 42% lighter than other pans, which lets you cook on the stove without breaking a sweat. Be it frying, searing, or baking, you can use this exceptional pan to meet all your cooking requirements.
What’s more, it is built to ensure even heat distribution, thereby making cooking a lot easier and faster. The handle has a good grip on it, making it easy to maneuver and control. This, in turn, makes cooking a lot less monotonous.
Apart from this, the product is available in 5 different sizes; you can choose the one that best suits your needs. Lastly, we were pleased to find out that it is backed by a lifetime guarantee, which ensures that you don’t have to incur additional expenses for replacements.
What Could’ve Been Better?
According to some user reviews, this pan is difficult to season. So, we suggest that the seasoning layers are well developed; you can use oil to build up the seasoning layers for the first few cooking sessions. And if you are still not satisfied, opt for a replacement.
- Backed by a lifetime guarantee
- Lightweight
- Can be used for various cooking purposes
- Comfortable to hold
- Hard to season
2. De Buyer Mineral B Frying Pan 5610.32
For over 200 years, De Buyer has been dedicated to producing quality and innovative cookware that meets the needs of both home cooks and catering professionals. On that note, we thought of introducing you to the De Buyer Mineral B Frying Pan that is engineered by following strict quality requirements to make it last longer.
- Carbon Steel Pan: 99% iron and 1% carbon, slippery with...
- The Darker The Better: Signature beeswax finish protects...
- Nonstick Kitchen Essentials: Has natural nonstick once...
- Made in France: Engineered and manufactured following the...
Why Did We Like It?
We pretty much loved everything about this product, but the signature handle is what caught our attention right from the start. It features a French curve, which makes it ideal for flipping, stirring, and sautéing. Plus, it is ergonomic, thereby providing users with an easy grip and balance.
We also liked that the rivets used are of the same quality as the carbon steel pan. This ensures that it contracts and expands at the same rate as the pan to prevent loosening over time. Beyond that, it comes with a beeswax finish, which helps fight against oxidation and aids in seasoning.
As far as the build quality is concerned, it is manufactured following the most strict quality requirements, thereby ensuring it lasts a lifetime. Long story short, it is one of the best carbon steel pans on the market.
What Could’ve Been Better?
To be honest, we couldn’t find any major downsides to this exceptional carbon steel pan. However, keep in mind that you cannot use it in the oven since its handle is coated. Other than this minor problem, it works perfectly.
- Ergonomically built
- Easy to use
- Rivets don’t loosen over time
- Highly durable
- Can’t be used in an oven
3. Lodge CRS12
Founded in 1896 in the United States, Lodge is among the best cookware suppliers. And CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet is a true testament to the brand’s quality and honest pricing. Pre-seasoned and ready to use, this product ensures that it delivers satisfying results without a hassle.
- 14 GAUGE CARBON STEEL heats quickly and retains heat for...
- Use on gas, electric, induction stovetops, outdoor grills or...
- Seasoned with oil for a natural, easy-release finish that...
- Easy care: hand wash, dry immediately, rub with cooking oil
Why Did We Like It?
As cookware from a brand that has been in the business for 125 years, this carbon steel skillet exceeded our expectations for most parts. It is made using a heavy gauge carbon steel material, which helps it maintain high and low temperatures. Not only does this make it a piece of highly practical cookware, but also brutally sturdy to last for decades.
You would be pleased to know that oil was baked into the pores of the steel during the manufacturing process to provide a natural non-stick cooking surface. This means you don’t need to go through the hassle of seasoning it after purchasing as it’s already been done beforehand.
Beyond that, its versatility makes it an ideal choice for users that love hosting backyard parties as it makes frying, roasting, and sautéing quite enjoyable. Not to mention, its high-quality surface is safe to use with sharp metal objects, including spatulas, forks, and knives.
Finally, the comfortable handle makes the pan easy to maneuver from the stove to the dining table.
What Could’ve Been Better?
While we were testing it for this review, we noticed that the pan doesn’t heat evenly. We measured the temperature around its edges and found out that it was almost 70 degrees hotter than the center. This a bit disappointing, given the brand’s goodwill.
- A versatile and practical option
- Comfortable to hold and maneuver
- Doesn’t require seasoning
- Top-notch durability
- Doesn’t heat evenly
4. Craft Wok 731W88
The next item on this list is another quality product from the house of Craft Wok, a brand that manufactures cookware that is made of 100% authentic carbon steel woks. It is equipped with a slew of useful features that work well to make your cooking experience pleasurable.
- Round Bottom Heavy 14 Inch 15 gauge (1.8mm) carbon steel...
- Not suitable for flat electric or flat induction stove....
- Hand hammered by Chinese professionals in Guangzhou. This...
- Steel helper handle will not burn when you stir fry over...
Why Did We Like It?
Straight off the bat, it comes with a round bottom, which makes it suitable for fast frying or for preparing different soups. We also loved the fact that this model was hand-hammered; hence it is sturdy and durable. Naturally, this makes the product the go-to choice for many professional chefs across the country.
Talking about the handle, it is made using wood, providing a tight and comfortable grip. Hence, you can rest assured that it will not slip when you stir-fry. Also, the steel helper handle deserves mention; it doesn’t burn when you stir fry on high heat and comes in handy for hanging the pan after cooking.
But that’s not all; we found that it comes with instructions for seasoning, which is not something you see with most other frying pans. So, from our experience, we are sure you won’t regret going with this model.
What Could’ve Been Better?
Since it sports a round bottom, it can be used only on wok burners and not on normal flat-top stoves. You will have to purchase a wok ring separately to keep the product in place over a flat cooking surface. Other than this issue, it does a decent job.
- Sturdy and durable
- Handle provides a tight and comfortable grip
- Comes with seasoning instructions
- Easy to store
- Requires additional purchases
5. Mauviel 3651.28
Mauviel is a leading France-based manufacturer of flagship cookware, known for its top-notch quality, design, and durability. On that note, allow us to introduce you to one of its premium innovations, the Mauviel M’Steel 3651.28, which can be used on various cooking surfaces.
- MADE IN FRANCE. Made of extra thick black steel /carbon...
- HIGH PERFORMANCE. Commercial grade durability withstands...
- NATURAL NON-STICK. Before first use, season the pan per...
- CAN BE USED ON ALL COOKING SURFACES. Gas, electric,...
Why Did We Like It?
For us, the main highlight is its build quality; it sports an extra thick black steel, which makes it sturdy and a classic heat conductor. This helps the pan withstand high temperatures for excellent searing. Plus, it is suitable for cooking on various surfaces, which is a bonus for us.
Once you season it, it becomes as good as a non-stick frying pan, and then you can use it for cooking various foods, except those that are acidic in nature. Not to mention, it is easy to clean; all you need to do is wash it in hot water and use a soft sponge to wipe it.
Like most Mauviel cookware, this one is backed by a lifetime warranty as well. You no longer have to worry about replacements as damages are covered by the brand. Overall, it is one of the best-looking carbon steel pans on this list.
What Could’ve Been Better?
The only gripe we have against this product is its steep price, which might be beyond the buying capacity of most home cooks and chefs. However, given the spectacular quality and features of this model, we’d recommend you to go for it.
- Backed by a lifetime warranty
- Can withstand high temperatures
- Sports a beautiful finish
- Easy to clean
- Tad bit expensive
6. BK CC002354-001
BK, a Dutch cookware brand that is known throughout the world for its heritage of innovation, brings you yet another sleek and stylish carbon steel pan. Meet the CC002354-001 Black Steel Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet that is designed to deliver incredible performance no matter where you are cooking.
- Since 1851, BK is the Royal Founder of the Dutch oven and...
- Black Steel is three times denser than aluminum, corrosion...
- Pre-seasoned with oil, this pan comes with a thin silicone...
- Designed to develop a natural nonstick patina layer, this is...
Why Did We Like It?
According to us, this model is a notch higher than induction cooktops and crepe pans. This is because it is made of black steel, which is denser than aluminum, and more durable than conventional grey carbon steel. Hence, this product is resistant to corrosion and can easily withstand temperatures up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit.
Furthermore, its heat-responsive design enables you to get the same searing results as cast iron quite easily. Also, users worried about seasoning will love that it comes with a thin silicone wax coating, which is a lot easier to remove than a layer of grease or beeswax. All you have to do is just wash it with soap, and you are ready to use it.
All things considered, it is a functional addition to a kitchen and helps in cooking meals to perfection.
What Could’ve Been Better?
Despite being such a practical option, it comes with a minor drawback. During our period of usage, we noticed that it doesn’t heat evenly. Even though it doesn’t affect the performance, we didn’t expect this at all from such a high-quality product from a renowned brand.
- Sports a corrosion-resistant and design
- Can withstand extreme temperatures
- Highly functional
- Delivers top-notch searing results
- Doesn’t heat evenly
7. Merten & Storck CC003336-001
We are halfway through our list, and now it’s time to talk about a budget-friendly model from Merten & Storck, a brand that is known for engineering cookware with top-notch precision. Compatible with all kinds of stovetops, the CC003336-001 Carbon Steel Black Frying Pan from the brand delivers unparalleled performance. Keep reading to know more.
- Lightweight and quick heating carbon steel delivers cast...
- Pre-seasoned, Merten & Storck Carbon develops a nonstick...
- Oven safe up to 600°F
- Metal utensil safe
Why Did We Like It?
We were honestly surprised by what this product brings to the table at such an affordable price. For starters, it sports a lightweight black carbon steel design, which heats super fast and is half the weight of cast iron.
Plus, this frying pan comes pre-seasoned right out of the box; hence you don’t have to worry about a laborious seasoning process. It develops a non-stick patina layer over time, which makes it suitable for nailing a perfect sear, crafting omelets, and frying fish without a grubby cleanup. Sounds impressive, doesn’t it? Well, there’s more.
It can be used on various stovetops, so it doesn’t matter where you are cooking; you can rely on this versatile pan for top-notch results. Lastly, it features an extremely affordable price tag, which makes this product an ideal choice for chefs that are starting new.
What Could’ve Been Better?
We were most satisfied with the performance of this budget-friendly frying pan. However, we felt that the sides were a bit too high, which could be an issue for a lot of people. But, given the price point, we don’t think users will mind this minor inconvenience.
- Sports an affordable price tag
- Features a lightweight design
- An ideal choice for new chefs
- Can be used on various stovetops
- The sides are a little high
8. Ballarini 75000-891
Our next pick is a highly functional 11″ Carbon Steel Fry Pan from Ballarini, an Italian brand that is popular for manufacturing and supplying premium household cooking equipment. Not only is this model built to meet your various cooking requirements, but it also sports an eye-catching design that can complement any kitchen.
- Durable, thick construction
- Boasts unparalleled heat retention for perfect browning and...
- Superior flat base stability – pan will not bulge
- Sloped side walls offer easy tossing and sauteing
Why Did We Like It?
We loved its eye-catching design and the various useful features right from the get-go! Sporting a thick and durable construction, it boasts unmatched heat retention for top-notch frying and browning. With this unit, you get the same results as cast iron, just without the annoying weight.
It comes with a flat base, which besides providing exceptional stability, prevents the pan from bulging. Coupled with a flat base are sloped sidewalls, which come in handy for sautéing and easy tossing and prevent the food from spilling.
Not only that, it is compatible with most cooking surfaces, including induction, which lets you take it to a friend’s backyard party and surprise them with your grilling skills. Overall, the integration of all these useful features makes this product one of the top-rated pans on the market, so it’s an option you wouldn’t want to miss out on.
What Could’ve Been Better?
Unfortunately, this pan doesn’t come pre-seasoned, which means you have to go through the hassle of seasoning it. We would strongly recommend you read the instructions that come with this model so that you can season it the right way.
- Sports an eye-catching design
- Provides exceptional stability
- Ideal for sautéing
- Compatible with most cooking surfaces
- Doesn’t come pre-seasoned
9. Winco CSFP-8
When it comes to quality cookware, Winco is one of the most reliable and affordable brands. So, it should be no surprise as to why we have included a product from this brand on our list. Measuring 8.625″ in diameter, the Winco CSFP-8 French Style Fry Pan offers a great cooking experience.
- Carbon steel
- Riveted handle
- Made in Spain
Why Did We Like It?
Weighing less than 2 pounds, it is one of the lightest carbon steel pans that you will ever come across. As a result, it makes the pan heat faster and easier to maneuver; therefore, it can be ideally used in a busy restaurant.
Chefs starting new will especially love its flat bottom and curved sidewalls, which prevent the food from spilling out and ensure complete cooking of all contents. Additionally, the frying pan is built with high-quality materials, making it capable of searing, sautéing, and frying as per requirements.
Another good thing about this model is that the pan and handle are not welded; instead, they are connected by rivets to ensure a long-lasting and reliable construction. Now, as far as the pricing is concerned, you will be glad to know that it is extremely economical. In fact, it is one of the most budget-friendly option that we have reviewed.
Overall, one of the best carbon steel pans that any cooking enthusiast can hope to get their hands on.
What Could’ve Been Better?
The carbon steel used on this model is on the thinner side, which does help in faster heating, but the heating may not be evenly spread across the surface. Moreover, since it is thin, it’s more susceptible to warping.
- Comes at an economical price
- Sports a lightweight design
- Highly versatile
- Built with high-quality materials
- Susceptible to warping
10. Mecete Wok Pan 5th Generation
Mecete is a relatively new entrant to the market, however the 5th generation Wok from the brand is as good as the other options on the list. Sporting a steady and strong handle, it is a perfect choice for professional chefs looking for reliable and high-quality cookware. Keep reading to know more.
- A gift from Chinese Ancient Cook skill: Mecete Chinese hand...
- Uncoated and No bubbles: Comparing with the machine-making...
- Iron dissolved in Cooking: It has great thermal conductivity...
- Steady Handle: Mecete Traditional Hand Hammered Uncoated...
Why Did We Like It?
The thing that we liked the most about this cookware is its build quality. You would be pleased to know that it is made with premium quality wrought iron, which gives it firm and uniform design. This ensures that you can use it for years without worrying.
Plus, it has an uncoated surface, which means you can enjoy a healthy and relaxing cooking experience. We were also impressed by its top-notch thermal conductivity, which ensures that it transfers the heat of the fire directly to the food to make it delicious and nutritious.
Apart from this, it comes with a sturdy yet comfortable-to-hold handle, which enables chefs to cook for hours at a stretch. Hence, it is one of the best wok pans available on the market.
What Could’ve Been Better?
To be honest, we didn’t find anything that could be labeled as faulty in this special wok pan. And for that reason, the product sports a hefty price tag, so it’s certainly not a product for every cooking enthusiast. However, given its quality, it’s certainly an investment worth making.
- Premium and durable build quality
- Can be used for years
- Helps in cooking a healthy and tasty meal
- Comfortable to hold
- Sports an expensive price tag
11. Delihom 606650
Now that we are nearing the end of the list, here’s another product from Delihom that you should consider. Made with pure carbon steel, the 606650 from the brand promises to deliver top-notch heat retention for cooking a wide range of dishes and even desserts. So, let’s dig a little deeper.
Related Posts
![How To Make A Resin Geode [Complete Guide]](https://cdn.homesthetics.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/resin-geode-1.jpg){kind=small}
November 2024 Editor’s Letter
From geo-exchange systems to mass timber, university campuses are leading the way...
RIBA’s President-elect Chris Williamson pens defense of...
I find that competitions are stimulating, exciting and keep up the momentum of thinking...
Ruggable review: these washable rugs are the perfect interiors...
… to find a design you like. Pros Beautiful designs Washable Personalisation option...
Houzz Tour: Forever Home on a Scenic Island (22 photos)
Ready for retirement, this Seattle couple sold their business and headed to an island...
OFFICEUNTITLED (OU) seeking Business Development Specialist...
OFFICEUNTITLED (OU) is hiring a Business Development Specialist to join our innovative...